For the kids © Getty Images Facebook was in the hot seat Thursday at a Senate hearing about children's safety online, with the company’s head of global safety Antigone Davis appearing virtually as the sole witness. The Senate Commerce consumer protection subcommittee hearing followed a series of reports from The Wall Street Journal citing internal Facebook research, in part about Instagram’s impact on teen mental health and the company's efforts to court young users. The backlash: Senators across the aisle were mostly unified in their anger at Facebook — raising questions about content on Instagram that appear to promote self injury and eating disorders. Subcommittee Chair Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) said Facebook is using “big tobacco’s playbook.” “It has hidden its own research on addiction, and the toxic effects of its products. It has attempted to deceive the public and us in Congress about what it knows and it has weaponized childhood vulnerabilities against children themselves,” Blumenthal said. “As the chairman said, you've lost the trust and we do not trust you with influencing our children,” said Ranking Member Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.). Facebook’s plans to create an Instagram for kids under 13 was a hot topic at the hearing, despite the company announcing earlier this week it would pause the plan. Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) pressed Davis on who would make the ultimate decision on whether to proceed with the plan. Davis responded that it would be part of a collaborative team decision. As with many of her questions, Klobuchar said she would follow up in writing with the company to receive more direct answers. Sen. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) asked Davis a handful of targeted questions about a potential kids’ platform, including if Facebook would commit to not launch any kids’ platform that allows with influencer marketing or contains “like buttons” and “follower counts.” Davis said the company will discuss those questions with experts to decide what is age appropriate. “It’s not acceptable that you don't have answers for these questions right now. These are the obvious problems that exist,” Markey said. In addition to Davis’s testimony, on Wednesday night Facebook released some of the slides of research the Journal reported on with annotations added to the slides to provide context the company said was missing from the reports. Looking ahead: Next week senators will hear from a Facebook whistleblower at a hearing on the same topic. Blumenthal said there are also future hearings in the works to hear from other tech platforms regarding kids’ online safety. Advocates have raised concerns about YouTube, especially in terms of potentially manipulative marketing tactics targeting young children, as well as the increasingly popular video-sharing app TikTok. It’s not yet clear if the additional spotlight on the issue will help push forward proposals aimed at adding further regulations for kids safety online, but during Thursday’s hearing Markey said he would reintroduce that day one such proposal, known as the KIDS Act. The proposal notably lacks GOP support. |