Former Vice President Joe Biden came under fire from fellow White House contenders during Wednesday night's debate, pummeled for defending Obama-era policies including the Affordable Care Act, deportations of immigrants during that administration, and his pitch to rejoin the Paris climate accord signed in 2016 and rejected by President Trump. Sens. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) and Cory Booker (D-N.J.), joined by New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio and former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro, took aim at Biden's record as vice president and as a senator from Delaware. "Everyone is talking about how terrible I was on these issues," Biden responded at one point, underscoring the extensive vetting he underwent before he joined former Sen. Barack Obama's ticket in 2008. "He chose me and said it was the best decision he made." Biden was better prepared and more combative during the debate in Detroit than he had been during the first debate in Miami, when he was caught off-guard by Harris's criticisms about his 1970s record on race and school desegregation, and his past opposition to school busing. The former vice president sparred with Harris on Wednesday about her "Medicare for All" plan, arguing it would be too expensive and unnecessary to push Americans away from private health coverage. She responded that Biden's approach to revive ObamaCare with improvements would leave millions of Americans without coverage. "For a Democrat to run for president with a plan that doesn't cover everyone is without excuse," she said. Booker and Castro leaped at openings to make a generational case against Biden, referring to his record, his ideas and his centrist approach to politics as retro and obsolete. Booker, who minutes before urged Democrats to holster their fire for one another to remain united, took aim at the former vice president's Senate support for the 1994 crime bill. "You're dipping at the Kool-Aid and you don't even know the flavor," Booker said, using street slang to audience applause. "This isn't about the past sir, it's about the present." "It sounds like one of us has learned the lessons of the past, and one of us hasn't," Castro said during a sharp back-and-forth with Biden about immigration. Biden, leaning on his oft-used dismissal — "malarkey" — defended his record, sometimes with tangled sentences to return fire, arguing that Booker, as the former mayor of Newark, N.J., for eight years, had "done nothing" about the city's controversial policing. Despite the slings and arrows at Biden, some of his supporters said they were pleased with the performance, especially after his wobbly showing in June, which alarmed some Democrats who backed him as a front-runner. "I'm very happy with Biden's performance," said one close Biden supporter, who asked for anonymity. "I'm really surprised by the attacks by a number of them on the Obama record Is attacking Obama's record really a winner in a Dem primary race??!! Hard for me to see that." Among the winners in Wednesday's debate is Booker, who turned in a strong performance to boost his presence after struggling to impact the race for months. Niall Stanage writes that while Booker didn't have a single moment in the debate, he was consistently strong and asserted himself as a major player. On the losing end was Harris, who sought to follow up on her impressive performance in Miami. Her status in the Democrats' top tier put a target on her back, and not just from Biden. Multiple candidates opened the opposition research book against her. She came under siege during one particularly scathing attack by Rep. Tulsi Gabbard (D-Hawaii) over her record on criminal justice and capital punishment as California attorney general. Gabbard accused the California Democrat of locking up scores of racial minorities on low-level drug offenses, of hiding evidence that would free an innocent man on death row, and said she kept people imprisoned for longer sentences to use them as cheap prison labor, leaving Harris looking rattled for the first time in the debate season. Harris told Gabbard that she was overseeing criminal justice in the state, adding the House lawmaker weighed in absent experience as a prosecutor. The back-and-forth came after Biden attacked Harris over her tenure as state attorney general, specifically that California had two districts that were more segregated than any in the country, adding that she turned a blind eye to rogue police departments. Elsewhere, Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) struggled once again as she continues to have trouble putting her stamp on the primary race. She was on the losing end of a back-and-forth with Biden after she accused him of opposing women working outside the home, with the former vice president noting his work to pass the Violence Against Women Act and the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act. "I don't know what happened, except you're now running for president," Biden retorted. From the two debates, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) emerged as winners. Both stood their ground in the face of attacks from centrists and their performances gained altitude with supporters. Wednesday night's event, on the other hand, unveiled more mixed reviews about the candidates on stage. Biden and Harris dominated the speaking time on Wednesday night, with Biden speaking for 21 minutes and Harris for more than 17 minutes. No other candidate eclipsed 13 minutes. The Hill: Senate Democrats see proposals from Warren, Sanders as unfeasible. The Hill: Winners and losers from two nights of debates in Detroit. The Hill: Ugly divisions on display as Democrats turn on each other. The Hill: Top moments during Detroit debate on Wednesday. The Hill: Five takeaways on second debate night in Detroit. The Hill: Booker to Biden on Obama: "You can't have it both ways." Wednesday's debate also included Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.), who joined Biden in criticizing Harris's approach to health care reform and spoke powerfully about education. Entrepreneur Andrew Yang drew laughter for contrasting himself with Trump as "the Asian man who likes math." Washington Gov. Jay Inslee capitalized on opportunities to describe the urgency of tackling climate change. The Hill: Harris faced attacks from Biden, Bennet and Gabbard on health plan. The Democratic National Committee is skipping August and the next debate takes place September 12 and September 13 in Houston at Texas Southern University, a public historically black university and will be hosted by ABC News and Univision. The DNC raised the threshold for candidates to qualify to participate, meaning the number of debaters on stage in a few weeks could shrink, setting up a six-week sprint for candidates to hit the needed benchmarks. To date, seven candidates — Biden, Harris, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg, Booker and former Rep. Beto O'Rourke (D-Texas) — have qualified. Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) has qualified in polling, while Yang and Castro have both reached the donor threshold. This begs the question — which candidate will throw in the towel before Labor Day? As for Trump, he'll rally supporters tonight in Cincinnati in an attempt to rebut the 2020 field of challengers. Start time is 7 p.m. Perspectives & Analysis: Dan Balz: Wednesday's presidential debate turns on character as much as ideology, a foreboding turn for Democrats. The New York Times: Joe Biden did fine, and that might have been enough. Gail Collins: Debate drama: Here's Joe. Gerald F. Seib: Debates leave trio of presidential battles. Jonathan Bernstein: Democrats in Detroit debates know what they're talking about. © Getty Images
|
No comments:
Post a Comment