Republicans see pros and cons to Graham Platner’s last-minute decision to drop out of the Maine Senate race as Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) attempts to again defy political trends and win another term.
At least five Democrats have thrown their hats in the ring for an expected nominating convention that the state party will hold later this month to choose Platner's replacement, and others may enter the field.
Whoever is selected will almost certainly carry less baggage than Platner, a progressive oyster farmer who built a grassroots movement to win the Democratic nomination, only to bow out in the face of sexual assault allegations this week.
The new Democratic nominee will also inherit some potential disadvantages in running what will be an abbreviated campaign.
Some Republicans said they more optimistic than ever about Collins’ chances.
“I think that Platner soared initially because he is a unique and talented personality,” said Lance Dutson, a GOP strategist who formerly served as communications director for Collins’s 2014 campaign. “He's a good speaker, and he's got an interesting and unique backstory.”
“The odds of them being able to pull that off again ... there's nobody with just even the slightest of dynamism to them,” he added.
Still, some Republicans have expressed concerns that Collins’s challenge is about to become tougher.
A person familiar with the Collins campaign’s thinking told Politico that the campaign viewed Platner as a uniquely vulnerable opponent with all of his controversies.
Conservative commentator Charlie Sykes said on MS NOW that Collins may be in more difficult territory than she was a few weeks ago.
“If the Democrats do not tear themselves apart and they do nominate somebody who does not have that kind of baggage, then Susan Collins faces a lot of headwinds, not merely as a Republican, but... in a year which I think incumbents, particularly elderly incumbents, are not faring well,” Sykes said.
The Hill has reached out to Collins’s campaign for comment.
Many Democrats thought Collins was ripe for removal in 2020, with then-state House Speaker Sara Gideon on the ticket in a presidential election year. But the incumbent outperformed polling significantly, defeating her by nearly 9 points.
That was the closest race Collins faced since her first Senate election in 1996.
Senate Republicans’ campaign arm expressed confidence that Collins would be able to continue the pattern.
“Susan Collins has defeated every DC-anointed candidate Chuck Schumer has sent her way, and she’ll defeat whichever loser comes out of this process as well,” National Republican Senatorial Committee regional press secretary Samantha Cantrell said in a statement.
Democrats coming out of the convention unified is a considerably big “if.” The candidates are already jockeying for the top position ahead of the convention, and progressives who backed Platner are showing early signs of rallying around former state Senate President Troy Jackson.
Jackson, fresh off an unsuccessful run for governor, was an early and ardent backer of Platner. That could benefit him in winning the nomination but also could prove to be a liability in the general election.
Jackson told MS NOW that the sexual assault accusations against Platner were a “red line” that he wouldn’t cross.
Other candidates are less tied to Platner but have their own potential vulnerabilities. That includes Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows, who already faced Collins in 2014 and lost by more than 30 points.
Regardless of who emerges as the nominee, they would have just a bit more than 100 days to get their name and message across to voters, also starting at a severe fundraising disadvantage to Collins.
Even the candidates who have money left over from their unsuccessful gubernatorial bids cannot touch it for their Senate candidacy under state-to-federal fundraising rules.
Dutson expressed a dim view about Republicans’ chances broadly in the midterms, saying he expects a “bloodbath” for the GOP in the shadow of the Trump administration. But Collins may buck that.
“It’s been the story of Maine for 30 years or more, especially when Collins’s on the ballot,” Dutson said.
▪ The Hill: Dems fear chances of winning Senate could be slipping away.
▪ The Hill: Five lessons Democrats could learn from Platner’s exit.
No comments:
Post a Comment